Ahhh, the unique experience of watching soccer games accompanied by American commentators and produced by Americans. We don’t want to tie this to recent global geopolitical developments, namely the rising tide of anti-Americanism throughout the world, but theses games probably aren’t helping.
Soccer Friendly Producers?
The producers must have been hired out of the football or baseball world, judging by their love of on-screen graphics and obscure statistics. The camera angles are often awkward, making it difficult for the viewer to gain an accurate perspective. During the recent Galaxy-Chivas game, for example, viewers missed most of the scrum that followed the Beckham-Marsch confrontation, because the camera was on Beckham. Two red cards were issued, yet the viewer saw only half of the first booking, and missed the yellow card handed out to Marsch.
In addition, the replays are ill-timed, often inappropriate. These games often feature interviews in the middle of the action—sometimes there’s no soccer player interviewed at all, but the producers see fit to cut away from a game in progress to a solitary ‘correspondent’ for a pseudo-news ‘update.’
Commentator (In)Competence
Finally, the commentators. We’re thinking especially of the commentators for the U.S. men’s national team, who can do no wrong in their eyes. During the recent Copa America, in which the men’s team were thrashed by superior teams (though some point out that the men took what amounted to a ‘B’ squad composed mostly of younger players—an insult in itself to all of South America and to the storied tournament), their comments often ran to things like ‘an unfortunate result’ and ‘they deserved better’ and ‘the scoreboard did not reflect the game.’ In the recent U.S.-Sweden game, one of the commentators said ‘I liked the way they came out tonight,’ despite the team’s lackluster (to be generous) performance.
Regarding Eric Wynalda, we could write a whole article on why Eric drives us crazy but here is a few lines instead; There is no denying he has been there and done that but must he always manage to pepper each comment he makes with a personal (and boring) anecdote from his playing days, and lets not go into detail about his halftime “red cards” and “orange slices.” One can only hope that as soccer picks up in the US commentators will become more aware of the sport they are watching.
3 responses so far ↓
1 chaz litavic // Jan 19, 2008 at 5:55 pm
absolutly correct… thank god this game vs sweden will be on FSC. I agree with every word that is written obove . i dont have anything other to add… i only hope the usa, mostley mls squad will show some style and finish there chances to a victory tonight at the home depot center tonight.
2 Ian // Jul 15, 2008 at 7:26 pm
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eqth8Eo80EY
3 Anthony // Sep 1, 2008 at 2:40 pm
I know, I freaking hate it, I just can’t stand it anymore. When I watch Football(Soccer) on TV I feel like the commentators feel like I am an idiot. Why do they feel the need to teach me the sport every freaking game. I know that there are many, many new fans to Football (Soccer) in the US but geez!! Use the F’n internet if you don’t understand the game or use a second audio stream for educational purposes. I just don’t need your opinion after ever single play or pass for that matter. Its so bitter sweet for me. I am so grateful that there are so many outlets to view Football now so I really hate to complain but I can’t help it. I used to just turn down the center channel and that would mute them but now the networks are blending the audio in all 5.1 and I can’t kill them. I have instead started swithching the audio from my XBOX to play music instead. Why can’t the US networks just watch some of the EPL games and learn how to do it.
Ok, so sorry, my rant is now over. Thanks for reading.
Anthony
Leave a Comment